The Steel Magnolia's first fight was scheduled to be against T.D.M. However T.D.M. forfeited the match putting Steel Magnolia through to the next preliminary round where it faced Dark Steel. At the beginning of the match, The Steel Magnolia blew its drive motor and Dark Steel slammed it against the arena wall a few times before it was counted out. Dark Steel won by TKO, and Steel Magnolia was eliminated from the tournament. As of 2016 it is unknown if The Steel Magnolia participated in the Lightweight Consolation Rumble, even if it had it would not have been able to attend the Royal Rumble due to an incident with Nightmare which resulted in all rumbles getting canceled.
- Wins: 1
- Losses: 1
|Season 5.0||T.D.M. (Forfeit)||Dark Steel|